3 stars - Ok if you don’t mind the protein aftertaste
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
Ok if you don’t mind the protein aftertaste
NadyaF - Aug 4, 2026
I still think these taste very artificial, but I do like that there are no additional sweeteners in it. The flavor is very chalky to me, not really the taste I want after a workout. I don’t think there’s a funny smell or anything, it’s not lumpy and it goes down pretty smooth. It’s personally not a flavor for me though!
3 stars - Not bad
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
3 stars - Not My First Choice
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
3 stars - Not artificial tasting. Would buy again
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
3 stars - Interesting Mouth Feel
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
3 stars - Convenient with mediocre flavor
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
3 stars - High protein shake that’s convenient
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
3 stars - Good smooth protein shake
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
3 stars - It has a smooth, creamy texture and tastes great without being overly sweet
Average rating: 3 out of 5 stars
Page 45 of 50
Not bad
JPH6 - Jul 29, 2026
Pretty good vanilla flavor, not overly chalky, and pretty smooth consistency. Would prefer cleaner ingredients but would use post-workout, as a quick on-the-go protein snack, or meal replacement on a day where I want something lighter.
Not My First Choice
EmilyG - Jul 26, 2026
I was excited to try this product when I saw how much protein was in one serving. I'm a fan of the creamier protein drinks so this wasn't a personal favorite of mine. Also, if you like sweeter tasting drinks, this on on the low side of sweet.
Not artificial tasting. Would buy again
MaryL - Jul 24, 2026
This protein shake honestly taste better than I thought it would compared to a lot of the ones on the market. It does not taste chalky and the vanilla makes it palatable and not artificial tasting. The portion is a good meal replacement size and it was great that is had 42g of portion in that one bottle.
Interesting Mouth Feel
AdriannaC - Jul 23, 2026
The flavor is OK it sort of reminds me of a vanilla frosting and the smell is fairly mild. It does leave a bit of a powdery feeling in my mouth after the fact, but I did enjoy it with ice added as a refreshing drink post workout overall, I would drink it again, but it’s comparable to other protein drinks. 
Convenient with mediocre flavor
MorganP - Jul 23, 2026
My husband drinks a variety of protein powders and ready to drink protein shakes as a nurse on the go a lot. The vanilla flavor is mediocre, consistency is great, and aftertaste is a little “funky”. He said he has had worse, and has had better. It’s in convenient packaging for something quick to grab and go and the right amount of volume. Maybe a different flavor would be better?
High protein shake that’s convenient
CarolynW - Jul 22, 2026
I thought this protein shake was okay. The Vanilla crème flavor was smooth and not overly sweet but it did have a slight artificial aftertaste that became more noticeable after a few sips. It kept me full for awhile and the 42g of protein is definitely a plus if you’re looking for a convenient post workout or on the go option. The texture was creamy without being too thick. Overall it’s a decent protein shake that gets the job done!
Good smooth protein shake
LukasW - Jul 21, 2026
These muscle milk protein drinks are a great quick way to get your protein in for the day! Taste is pretty good, it’s got a nice vanilla smooth taste. Bottle design is sleek and nice to hold. Shake itself is not thick really at all which is nice. Overall with the taste I’d give it a 3/5, and for the protein intake it’s easily a 4.5/5. Great drink for athletes and non athletes!
It has a smooth, creamy texture and tastes great without being overly sweet
OriannysA - Jul 21, 2026
Ive really enjoyed this Muscle Milk Pro Protein Shake. It has a smooth, creamy texture and tastes great without being overly sweet. It's an easy way to get extra protein after a workout or when I need a quick snack during a busy day. It keeps me feeling full and energized, and I appreciate that it doesn't have a chalky aftertaste. I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a convenient, high-protein shake.