I really like the nutritional profile of this shake. Getting 42g of protein in one bottle is impressive, and I appreciate that it contains no added sugar or artificial sweeteners. It’s also made with ultra-filtered milk, which is a nice bonus. The reason I’m giving it 4 stars is simply the taste. Even though it’s sweetened with stevia, I found it much sweeter than I expected. For me, it was too sweet to finish the whole bottle comfortably. If you enjoy very sweet vanilla protein shakes, you’ll probably like this one. Personally, I prefer a more balanced sweetness, so I don’t think I’d purchase it again. That said, the nutrition and protein content are excellent.